Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Homeless Man Cleared of All Charges in Pipe Attack on Former San Francisco Fire Commissioner

A homeless man who brutally attacked the former San Francisco fire commissioner was found not guilty on all charges Friday.

Garret Doty, the now 25-year-old homeless man who was accused of beating 54-year-old Donald Carmignani repeatedly over the head with a metal pipe on April 5, faced two counts of assault and one count of battery.

Deputy Public Defender Kleigh Hathaway argued that Doty acted out of “fear for his life and fought back to protect himself.”

In a press release, the San Francisco Public Defender’s Office said that Carmignani’s attorneys previously shared only “select video footage” from the incident-leaving out how the altercation began.

Doty’s defense attorneys argued that Carmignani instigated the altercation and sprayed the homeless man with bear spray and threatened to stab and kill him if he did not move his belongings.

Carmignani previously said that three homeless people had set up an encampment near his mother’s front door, and she was afraid to leave her house in Marina District.

The San Francisco Public Defender’s Office said that after Carmignani allegedly threatened Doty, he decided to arm himself with a metal rod he found in a garbage bin.

The public defender’s said that 15 minutes later, Carmignai, “stood against a building and baited Doty to come closer” before spraying him with bear spray and ensuring the violent altercation.

A previous video released by Carmignani show Doty marching towards him with the metal rod and repeatedly hitting him.

Following the violent attack, Carmignani had 51 stitches, a fractured skull and a broken jaw.

Deputy Public Defenders Kleigh Hathaway said that it was “clear to her” that Doty was acting in self-defense against Carmignani.

“From the beginning, it was clear to me that Mr. Doty was acting in self-defense against Mr. Carmignani, who not only had the audacity to attack Mr. Doty with bear spray and then threatened to stab and kill Mr. Doty, but also presented himself as unwilling to back down from a fight that he had started,” said Hathaway. “Self-defense can be fierce because the brain goes into survival mode, and that fear response is sadly heightened for unhoused people, like Mr. Doty, who live in constant exposure.”

John Dennis, the Chairman of the San Francisco GOP, pointed to the city’s Democrat polices which put “residents under constant threat from street dwellers.”

“While San Francisco Republicans respect the judicial process, we’re disappointment that this violent act against a respected lifelong resident will go unpunished,” Dennis said in a statement to Fox News Digital. “San Francisco Democrat policies have put residents under constant threat from street dwellers. The outcome of this trial assures this sort of attack will happen again.”

The public defense also argued that Carmignani had previously used pepper spray against homeless people in the area on eight separate occasions.

Carmignani did not testify in Doty’s trial, but he did testify during the preliminary hearing where he invoked the Fifth Amendment against self-incrimination whenever he was questioned about any prior use of pepper or bear spray, the press release from the public defense said.

The former city official and his mother previously said that despite calling local police regarding the encampment of homeless people, police did not respond.

“To my knowledge, neither SFPD nor any of the city’s various homeless service providers responded to our 911 calls that morning,” he said.

Throughout the day, Doty’s group continued to bother his mother and his girlfriend, using drugs in public and harassing pedestrians on the sidewalk.

“My family has had prior interactions with these individuals, who have made repeated threats of violence to my family members,” he said. “As a result, my mother did not feel safe leaving her home.”

Carmignani said the group consisted of “known criminals” who have harassed area residents, vandalized property and have been seen using drugs in public.

“As a native San Franciscan and lifelong Marina District resident, I firmly believe that the city needs to promote the safety of its law-abiding citizens over those who chose to do drugs and commit violent acts in our streets,” he said. “I am hopeful that this unfortunate incident will lead to policy changes to better protect the interests of San Francisco residents and that my attackers will be fully prosecuted.”

  • Tamirose170 says:

    Now how about that NYC Subway Hero get all of his charges dropped and him released. He saved lives on the Subway that day when the black assailant taunted a group of riders and began thrashing at them — – – among 40+ additional times he has been caught and charged. This Veteran took him and held him in a position with another rider, so that he could not hurt himself or others until the subway stopped and the riders could get HELP.

    I think if we’re going to have EQUAL and HONEST Justice in all 50 States, the NYC Subway Hero should be released for Christmas and all charges dropped. I don’t think Victims care one iota about the color of a persons skin when they are attacking them – they merely want the painful, disabling, potential deadly attack to STOP – to CEASE – for the rider to have gotten help with medication in a proper treatment facility, as he should have been ordered by a NYC Judge any one of those 40+ trips before the Judge after he attacked riders or pedestrians in the streets.

    Americans want our Fair Justice System to Return! When someone does something wrong, something ILLEGAL, something against the Law (Federal, State or Local) – we want them PUNISHED so they learn a lesson of NOT to do that again! It is that simple! The color of the skin and what political party they are aligned with should NEVER be known or used as a determining factor on the outcome!

    Merry Christmas Donald J. Trump and Happy Birthday Baby Jesus! JESUS is the Reason for the Season. Let us ALL have Peace on Earth this Christmas. We need a 4-day Cease Fire across all of the world ~ Celebrate HIM ~

    ~ ~ Come Let Us Adore Him, Ring in the New Year and Make America Great Again 2024 ~ ~

  • EZ says:

    i want to read San Francisco Fire Commissioner is cleared of putting new breathing hole in homeless mans head

  • Joe says:

    Chicago, New York and San Francisco,, just to name a few of the cities which have been under democratic control. All if them are now feeling the effects of democrat control. And who is suffering ? The voters,, which by the way,, in San Francisco are nearly 80% democrats.

  • James Leamons says:

    Who got rights? HOMELESS got rights. Screw you taxpayer…



    The Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) is hiring illegal border crossers with Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals status and equipping them with guns to...


    Former President Trump would handily win the presidential election if it were held today – thanks in part to a stunning boost in support...


    The misconduct hearings on efforts to oust Fulton County DA Fani Willis from the Trump RICO case have come to a close. Both sides...


    Former President Donald Trump has defeated former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley in the Missouri Republican caucus, according to The Associated Press. In addition to...