Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?


Judge Rejects Arizona AG’s Attempt to Revoke Elections Agreement With County Recorder

An Arizona judge has rejected state Attorney General Kris Mayes’s attempt to terminate an agreement between Cochise County and the county recorder in a Thursday ruling.

The agreement, which was drafted in February 2023, permits the Cochise County’s recorder to be granted control over “almost all of the powers and duties of the election conferred by statute upon the Cochise County Board of Supervisors,” the document states.

After the initial agreement was written, Mayes filed a lawsuit in March on behalf of Arizona against the three Cochise County supervisors and the county recorder, citing that the agreement violates the Arizona Constitution and Arizona law, according to the documents filed.

In Tuesday’s hearing, Judge Howard Fell said the agreement was legal and the board couldn’t intervene with county recorders doing their job during elections.

“The Board does have the power to delegate at least some election duties to the recorder that is not otherwise specifically authorized by law,” Judge Fell said during a live stream of the hearing.

The state insinuated that the board’s move was part of a “pattern of exceeding their statutory authority with respect to elections,” according to the court documents.

“This effective transfer of the Board’s powers to the County Recorder has no statutory basis and threatens the right of Cochise County residents to have their elections conducted lawfully and transparently. The State has brought this action to prevent and redress those harms,” the statement read.

Arizona Attorney General Kris Mayes, expressed his concern over the delegation of duties by the county recorders and said it crossed a “legal line.”

“In addition to this broad transfer of power, I am deeply concerned this move might shield or obscure actions and deliberations the Board would typically conduct publicly under open meeting law,” Mayes said in a statement.

In response to the injunction, members of the board said their arrangement is “perfectly legal,” and the state shouldn’t interfere in their upcoming May election.

“The biggest flaw in the State’s argument is that even though the State pushes for a rushed resolution prior to the May 16, 2023, Cochise County Jail District vote, it ignores the fact that “the governing body of any election district authorized to conduct an election may contract with the board of supervisors and county recorder for election services,” the statement read.

Once the hearing concluded, State Attorney Joshua D. Bendor wasn’t sure what the next legal course of action would be as he “respectfully disagrees” with the judge’s ruling.

“They’ve said they’re hiring an Elections Director a week from today and there’s been some indication they’ll terminate the agreement after that. If they do maybe we’ve done all we need to do here, if things keep going we’ll have to see about what to do next,” he told News 4 Tucson outside the courthouse.

The county was sued for both attempting to implement illegal hand-counting procedures and for refusing to certify the results of the election, during last year’s 2022 midterm elections, according to documents.

Peggy Judd, a Cochise County Supervisor, was in attendance during the hearing Tuesday and was delighted with the outcome.

“I’m just pleased because I feel like we’ve had a lot of losses and a lot of what I would call public humiliation and I don’t blame anyone and for a bit of it I take credit but it felt good to have a judge say this is ok,” she told News 4 Tucson.

Cochise County resident George Preggatis drove up to Tucson to attend the hearing.

“I think the judge made the right decision. I believe the Cochise Board of Supervisors have retained their power and will continue to exercise it appropriately,” Preggatis said.

  • Deb says:

    It’s outrageous how these courts and judges ignore the fraud. They’re all in on it and if they have nothing to hide why aren’t they looking at it? We’ve got to find a fair minded judge who will see the whole picture. These judges they’ve had are all for the democrats

  • james V faber says:

    end of story

  • Tressa says:

    We need to do something! We are just keyboard warriors! We need to demand action from our NRCC, I keep getting emails from them asking for money, sorry NRCC I don’t waste my money unless I see some action on their part besides sitting on their hands!

    We need to demand impeachment of veggie joe and the hoe! They impeached President Trump for less!
    Getting our borders closed until we know who they let in unverified and get them out or in prison.

    Get voter registration cleaned up removing the dead still registered to vote. One day voting and counting in one day only and no more machines which means paper ballots and no more mail in ballots until you are disabled or in the military!

    Demand term limits of only two terms and no more since this is what happened when they are in for decades and won’t retire! They get to rubbing elbows with our enemies like veggie joe!

    Go after the brainwashing media and get them , if they stay, start speaking the facts with out their opinion. We know the people can think for ourselves.

    I hate liars can’t trust them!
    We being keyboard warriors and with today equipment we all can send e-mails message to all the Republicans leaders all at once!
    It’s going to take a while to data enter them all. We can over load them to Make them wake up, no donations until we see some action!

    We don’t need to cuss them out because we are better than the Democrats party.

    So wake people we are losing our country and our freedom.
    Do it for all those you love and for future generations!

  • George Z says:

    Election fraud is systemic NATIONWIDE. Why? The SCOTUS has outlawed state election officials asking voter registration applicants for proof of citizenship! Proof of citizenship is not necessary.
    One answering that question “yes” or “no” is accepted on face – an applicant is under the honor system. Couple that with the Motor-Voter laws requires that every person applying for a driver’s license must be provided with a voter registration application. With 20 to 30 million illegals in our country (and counting) do you think we have a problem? Do you understand now why Dem’s want open borders?



    In April 2024, after being locked up since August 2023, J6er Julio Baquero found out that he had Stage 4 cancer and, fortunately, was...


    Nvidia has been on an impressive run the previous year, extending well into 2024 and showing no sign of waning, bringing hefty profits to...


    CBS News was forced to remove a video from social media platform X on Wednesday after arguing it was an example of a “cheap...


    A leftist MSNBC contributor has been raked over the coals for claiming Donald Trump is really the presidential candidate who needs to be helped...